If you’re a pet parent, you already know that not every condo community in Sarasota and Manatee is welcoming to four-legged family members—especially if you have large dogs or more than one pup. The good news? There are some wonderful options in Longboat Key, Venice, and Siesta Key where your pets can feel just as at home as you do.
Below is a helpful breakdown of communities that stand out for buyers with a budget between $500,000 and $950,000 who want the flexibility of having two large dogs.
Longboat Key
Windward Bay
A bayside community with beach access just across the street. Windward Bay is one of the few spots that allows up to two dogs, each around 75 lbs. Residents enjoy marinas, pools, tennis, pickleball, and a friendly social atmosphere. Pricing typically ranges from the mid-$500s into the $800s, making it one of the most approachable choices on Longboat Key.
Pelican Harbour & Beach Club
Stretching from the bay to the beach, Pelican Harbour is another great find for pet owners, with rules allowing two dogs up to 101 lbs. You’ll find condos here starting in the high-$600s, with many falling right into the sweet spot of our budget range. With private beach access, tennis courts, and a one-month minimum rental policy, it’s a flexible choice for both full-time and seasonal residents.
Venice
The Waterfront on Venice Island
Located right on the Intracoastal, The Waterfront offers both fantastic views and the rare allowance of two dogs with no weight limit. Condos here often list from the $600s to the $800s, providing excellent value for those who want to be close to downtown Venice and its charming shops and restaurants.
San Lino
A bit east of the Island, San Lino is a well-kept community where many listings note allowances for two pets up to around 100 lbs. It’s a terrific option if you want newer construction and more space, with prices generally running in the $300s to $500s—well under the top end of the budget.
Siesta Key
Here’s where things get tricky. Siesta Key is a dream for beach lovers, but most condo associations there limit pets to either one small dog or none at all. The communities that do allow two large dogs tend to be at a much higher price point, often $1 million and up.
For example, Summer Cove allows two pets up to 100 lbs, but units typically list well above our target range. Hamilton Club, a townhome-style community, is similar—pet friendly but usually priced in the million-dollar bracket.
Key Takeaways
-
If pet-friendly rules are at the top of your list, Longboat Key and Venice will offer the most realistic options within the $500k–$950k range.
-
Windward Bay, Pelican Harbour, The Waterfront on Venice Island, and San Lino are four strong communities to explore first.
-
Siesta Key is wonderful for lifestyle, but it may require stretching your budget if two large dogs are non-negotiable.
Final Thoughts
Buying with pets means balancing lifestyle, location, and rules that truly fit your family. The condo documents can be confusing, and pet restrictions sometimes vary even between buildings in the same community. That’s why I always double-check the association’s current policies before moving forward on an offer.
If you’d like a curated list of today’s available condos that allow two large dogs, just reach out—I’d be happy to share the most up-to-date matches and even schedule a tour.
