When you live in paradise, it’s easy to forget that even Sarasota has a darker side to its history. I was struck recently when reading about how September 10th has consistently proven to be one of the most disastrous days on our calendar. From hurricanes to earthquakes, and even tragic human events, this date has an odd way of showing up in Sarasota’s story.
Hurricanes That Made History
We all know Sarasota is no stranger to hurricane season, but September 10th seems to carry extra weight.
-
Hurricane Donna (1960) roared through Florida on this date with winds of 145 mph, before sweeping past Sarasota and Venice with destructive force. While the worst of it missed us, the area still suffered flooding and wind damage. Donna was such a fierce storm her name was permanently retired
-
Decades later, on September 10, 2017, Hurricane Irma became one of the most feared storms in modern history, sparking the largest mass evacuation in U.S. history. By the time it reached Sarasota-Bradenton, winds had thankfully weakened, but Irma still managed to destroy the beloved Anna Maria Island Pier, which had been standing since 1911.
If that wasn’t enough, two years later—again on September 10—a barge accident damaged the new pier under construction.
And as if nature wanted to make a point, September 10 also marks the peak of the Atlantic hurricane season.
An Earthquake Felt in Florida
Florida is not known for earthquakes, but on September 10, 2006, a 6.0 magnitude quake struck 251 miles off Anna Maria Island. Many residents reported feeling walls shake and clothes move on hangers. While no damage was recorded, it was the first time Floridians had felt an earthquake since 1952.
Violence at Club Elite
September 10th’s shadow isn’t just natural disasters. In 2011, a tragic shooting at Club Elite in Palmetto left two people dead and 26 wounded. The violence rattled the community and is remembered as one of the darkest nights in local history.
A Presidential Connection
Even President George W. Bush is tied to this date. On September 10, 2001, he arrived in Sarasota ahead of his visit to Booker Elementary School. What started as a routine trip became forever etched in history the very next morning with the events of 9/11.
What Does It Mean for Sarasota?
As a Realtor, I often talk with clients moving to Sarasota about the realities of living here—our beautiful beaches, world-class arts, and welcoming communities, but also our hurricane preparedness and storm history. September 10 is a reminder that while Sarasota shines 364 days a year, nature and history have left their mark on this one date.
Still, what strikes me most isn’t just the disasters—it’s the resilience of this community. From rebuilding piers to raising flags after storms, Sarasota always finds a way to endure and even grow stronger.
